Property Tax Assessed Value vs Market Value Difference Explained

Understanding the difference between tax assessed value vs market value for your property is critical to financial planning. These two measurements have distinct roles in the valuation of your home, yet they often cause confusion among homeowners.

In this guide we’ll delve into these concepts, clarifying their meanings and implications for your property ownership.

What Is the Difference Between Assessed Value and Market Value?

The main difference between market value and assessed value is that market value of a property reflects the potential selling price based on current trends, recent sales of comparable properties, and the property’s condition, whereas assessed value is a valuation set by the local government, often a percentage of the market value.

It’s crucial to understand these differences as they have distinct financial implications:

• Market value: can influence your decision on when to sell or buy.
• Assessed value: impacts the amount of property tax you owe.

Recognizing and leveraging these values can help you make informed decisions and potentially save money.

For example, let’s say that the tax assessed value vs asking price is significantly different for your property. If the fair market value of homes is higher than the assessed value, it could be a good time for its owners to sell and get higher returns.

However, if the assessed value is higher than the market value, then owners are probably better off holding on to the property and avoid losing a significant amount of money on taxes.

What Does Assessed Value Mean?

The assessed value of a property, in simple terms, is the value determined by your local government for the purpose of calculating property taxes. It takes into account factors such as:

• Property’s condition
• Location
• Comparable properties in the area.

Diving deeper into this definition of the assessed value meaning, think of assessed value as something that your local government assigns to ensure uniform and fair taxation across properties within their jurisdiction. It’s not necessarily reflective of the actual market value, but rather used as a basis for property taxes.

Note that assessed value is often a percentage of the market value and can vary from one jurisdiction to the next due to different assessment rates. Assessed value in California, for example, is usually equal to the purchase price and then adjusted upward each year by 2%.

It typically accounts for any exemptions or discounts you might be eligible for, and the final figure is often lower than the market value.

So while this value might not directly influence your selling price, it certainly impacts your annual property tax, and understanding it can help you better manage your finances.

And Market Value?

The market value of the property, essentially, is the amount that a buyer is willing to pay for your property in the current real estate market. Market value is used to determine fair prices and the value of the home, as opposed to assessed value, which is calculated for tax purposes. It tends to fluctuate over time according to market conditions, including:

• Supply and demand
• Interest rates,
• Overall health of the economy

Unlike the assessed value, the market value is not used for taxation purposes, but it is of great importance if you’re considering selling or refinancing your property. For example, let’s say that you’re selling your house to a real estate investor — high market value means you can set a higher selling price, potentially maximizing your profit. 

Understanding the market value of your home allows you to make strategic decisions about when to sell, how to price your home, and whether improvements could increase your home’s value. You can obtain an estimate of your property’s market value through a comparative market analysis (CMA) or through an appraisal conducted by a licensed professional.

Knowing your home’s market value is not merely about numbers; it’s about understanding your property’s worth in the eyes of potential buyers and making educated decisions that could lead to financial benefits. It’s this knowledge that provides the power to negotiate effectively, whether you’re buying or selling.

Tax Assessed Value vs Market Value Comparison Chart

So, how does assessed value compare to market value?

This chart provides an at-a-glance summary of the differences between then two, but we dive deeper into each of the comparison right below it.

Comparison	Assessed value	Market value
Purpose	Used for property taxation purposes	Used for buying/selling or refinancing purposes
Determined by	Local government	Current real estate market conditions and comparable recent sales
Calculating	Property condition, location, and comparable sales in the area	Supply and demand, interest rates, economic health
Fluctuation	Varies by jurisdiction and assessment rate	Changes with market conditions
Frequency of evaluation	Typically every year	Typically before buying/selling or refinancing
Potential Impact	Affects annual property tax obligations	Affects selling price and potential profit

Tax Assessed Value vs Market Value Purpose

The tax assessed value, as established by local government, is instrumental in determining your annual property tax. A higher assessed value indicates a higher tax obligation. This value is typically reassessed annually and can change based on improvements to the property or the area. 

In contrast, the market value is a dynamic and somewhat unpredictable figure that shifts in response to market conditions and trends. This value is paramount when you’re planning to sell or refinance your property.

Note that while the assessed value and market value serve different purposes, they aren’t completely unrelated. Improvements that increase your property’s market value might also lead to an increase in its assessed value, and thus higher property taxes.

Therefore, a balanced understanding of both is crucial for making sound financial and property decisions.

Fair Market Value vs Assessed Value Determination

The determination of assessed vs market value involves distinct processes and factors. For one thing, the assessed value is determined by a local tax assessor who takes into account the property’s condition, location, and comparable sales in the area.

The assessor may also apply a predetermined assessment ratio, which might not be 100% of the market value of a property. The goal here is to ensure an equitable distribution of property taxes across the jurisdiction. 

On the other hand, the fair market value is determined by the current real estate market conditions. It’s based on what a willing and informed buyer would pay the seller for a particular property, assuming no pressure on either party.

Calculating Property Tax Assessment vs Market Value

if you want to know how to calculate assessed value vs market value, the parameters for each are quite different and can make the process fairly complex. While there’s no direct assessed value vs market value calculator (because the values are determined differently), the assessed value is used for property taxes, while market value is used primarily for sale or refinance decisions.

There are free tools and resources that you can use to calculate for market value. One good example is Zillow’s Zestimate home valuation calculator. 

Assessed value, on the other hand, will require the expertise of a local tax assessor, who will take into account various factors such as property condition, location, and comparable sales. However, you can also do a comparative market analysis by researching the assessed values of similar properties in your area and using that information to estimate your own property’s assessed value.

Once you get the values, it’s then a matter of comparing one against the other. Ideally, you’d want the market value to be higher than the assessed value to maximize your potential profits when selling. However, it’s essential to keep in mind that each property and jurisdiction is unique, and there might be other factors at play that could impact these values. 

Property Tax Value vs Market Value Fluctuation

Similarly, the fluctuation of both assessed home value vs market value depends on various factors.

Both values can change depending on the rate of assessment set by the local jurisdiction. They can also change significantly if the property is improved or if the neighborhood’s desirability increased due to new development or infrastructural changes.

Having said this, market value is more volatile and tends to change more rapidly due to the fluid nature of real estate market conditions since it’s affected by:

• Overall economic health
• Interest rates
• Supply and demand dynamics

For instance, if your area becomes popular and demand for homes increases, the market value of your property could skyrocket. Conversely, a sudden economic downturn might lead to a drop in market value. 

Assessed Value vs Market Value Evaluation Frequency

The evaluation frequency can also vary significantly.

Assessed value is typically evaluated on a fixed cycle (often annually), but can differ based on your local government’s policies.

Market value, on the other hand, is continuously fluctuating due to its direct correlation with current real estate market conditions.

Understanding the frequency of these evaluations is fundamental in making timely and informed decisions related to your property. For example, being aware of when your property’s assessed value will be evaluated can help you anticipate potential changes to your property taxes. 

Market Value vs Assessed Value Impact on Property Decisions

When purchasing a property, the market value will often play a pivotal role and will determine not only the purchase price but also the amount you can potentially borrow for a mortgage. 

But what about assessed value? How does tax assessment relate to property value? And based on the assessed value, how does tax assessment relate to the value of the home?

Well, the simple answer is that it directly influences your property tax obligation. A higher assessed value means higher property taxes, and vice versa. Having an insight into your property’s assessed value can help you estimate your annual tax dues and enable you to plan your budget accordingly. 

In some situations, selling a house below market value might be a strategic choice for homeowners looking to avoid extensive repairs, expedite the sale, or accommodate certain tax advantages, although it typically results in lower returns. Whether selling at, above, or below market value, knowing both values can help in making a financially sound decision.

Is Assessed Value Better Than Market Value? Our Final Points

Assessed value and market value, while both related to your property, serve different purposes and should be prioritized based on your specific needs.

When buying or selling a property, market value is crucialsince it estimates the selling price in the current real estate market. A property listed close to its market value attracts potential buyers. Similarly, lenders use the market value to determine lending amounts for mortgage refinancing.

However, if you’re a homeowner concerned about managing your annual budget and understanding your tax obligations, the assessed value is more significant. This is the value used by local governments to calculate your property taxes. A lower assessed value means lower property taxes, which can be beneficial for long-term homeowners who have budget constraints.

The bottom line is that neither value is inherently better than the other; instead, their importance depends on the homeowner’s purpose and financial situation. Understanding the importance of both these values and how they’re calculated can enable you to make sound decisions when buying or selling a property.

FAQs